Arlecchino, known in-game as The King of Riddles, calls you five times over the course of Lies of P. Get his riddles right, and you walk away with rare gear. Get one wrong, and that phone goes dead for the rest of your playthrough. Below is every Lies of P riddles answer, its exact location, and what happens if you slip up.

Since launch, Lies of P has sold more than 3 million copies and reached 7 million total players across PC and consoles, according to Notebookcheck — a big reason so many players are hunting these riddle solutions right now.

All Lies of P Riddles Answers and Locations

Here’s every riddle Arlecchino asks, in the order you’ll likely reach them, with the correct answer bolded.

Riddle 1 – Krat City Hall Courtyard, near Workshop Union Entrance (Chapter II)
The riddle: “By morning, it walks on feet numbering four. At mid-day just two, no less and no more. It walks on three feet when the evening arrives.”
Your choices are Human or Monster. The answer is Human — a nod to the classic Sphinx riddle about the stages of life.

Riddle 2 – Malum District (Chapter V)
The riddle: “I stand tall and proud when I’m young and bold. But I’m short and humble once I’ve gotten old.”
Pick between Boa Constrictor and Candle. The answer is Candle, since a candle shrinks as it burns down.

Riddle 3 – Grand Exhibition Gallery (Chapter VII)
The riddle: “What cannot be used before it breaks?”
Choose between Egg and Glass. The answer is Egg. Here’s the twist most guides skip: Arlecchino won’t hand over the Trinity Key right away. He gives a second clue about “the woman of cold,” which points you to a marble statue nearby. Check the statue’s fingertips carefully — that’s where the actual key is hidden.

Riddle 4 – Krat Central Station Street (Chapter IX)
The riddle: “This blue flower has many ways to take root. But only on one man does it ever bear fruit.”
Your options are A Bruise and Ergo. The answer is Ergo, the game’s core currency and crafting resource.

Riddle 5 – The Final Confession (after all four Trinity Doors are opened)
This last call isn’t a riddle. It’s a confession: “Is Geppetto’s creation a killer? A no or a yes.”
Your choices are Yes and No. Yes is the answer that unlocks The Chosen One’s Trinity Key instantly. Choosing No still gets you the key eventually, through a Surprise Box, but it also triggers extra dialogue and a temporary decay effect on your character.

Must Visit: 125+ Hard Riddles With Answers That Will Seriously Challenge Your Brain in 2026

Do You Have to Get Every Lies of P Riddle Right?

No, you don’t have to answer every riddle correctly to finish the game. But skipping them means missing out on some of the best early gear in Lies of P.

Here’s the catch: there’s no retry within the same playthrough. Once you answer wrong, that phone line goes permanently silent. The only fix is starting New Game+, where all five riddles reset and you get another shot. This is why so many players keep a written answer list handy before picking up any ringing phone.

Is Geppetto’s Creation a Killer? The Final Riddle Explained

This isn’t really a riddle — it’s a moral gut-check woven into the game’s central theme of lying versus honesty. Pinocchio, the puppet you control, has killed dozens of enemies by the point this question is asked.

Saying Yes is the “honest” answer and rewards you immediately with the final key. Saying No is framed as a lie, and the game punishes that lie with a decay debuff, even though you still receive the key afterward. Either choice completes the riddle questline and unlocks the achievement tied to finishing all five calls.

Must VISIT: 360+ D&D Riddles With Answers: Epic, Tricky & Mind-Bending Puzzles for Your Next Adventure

Tips to Never Miss a Lies of P Riddle Call

A few practical habits make this whole quest line much smoother:

• Answer quickly. Each call runs on a timer, so decide fast once you pick up.
• Explore in any order. The five riddles aren’t locked to a strict sequence, so if you missed one earlier, backtrack using the nearest Stargazer checkpoint.
• Watch your dialogue progress. Some players have found that Riddle 2’s call in the Malum District won’t trigger until certain conversations with side characters have advanced. If a phone stays silent, try progressing a related NPC’s story first.
• Don’t forget the follow-up puzzle on Riddle 3. Getting the answer right isn’t the end — you still need to find the hidden key at the statue.

FAQs

What is the answer to the riddle in Lies of P?

There are five separate riddles, and each has its own answer: Human, Candle, Egg, Ergo, and Yes (or No) for the final confession.

What is the answer to the final riddle in Lies of P?

The final call asks whether Geppetto’s creation is a killer. The intended answer is Yes, though choosing No still rewards you with the key through a different path.

What is the answer to the fourth riddle in Lies of P?

The fourth riddle, found on Krat Central Station Street, is solved with Ergo.

Do you have to get all riddles right in Lies of P?

No. Getting them right only unlocks bonus gear through Trinity Doors. Wrong answers lock that riddle until New Game+.

Is Geppetto’s creation a killer?

In the story’s context, yes — Pinocchio has killed many enemies by that point, which is why the game treats “Yes” as the truthful answer.

Conclusion

Five phone calls, five answers, and a handful of hidden gear waiting behind Trinity Doors — that’s the whole riddles system in Lies of P. Keep this list handy, answer fast, and you’ll walk away with every reward on your first playthrough.